May 19, 2012 10 users online
 
 

OBSERVER COLUMN FOR FRIDAY, APRIL 10, 1998

The Hanes Closure: A vote of confidence in Jamaican Management?

Utterance by Leahcim Semaj

The closure of the Hanes Plant in Sandy Bay, Hanover on Monday has
generated maximum media coverage and concern. I have heard a number of
live radio interviews with company officials. All the interviewers tried to get
the Sara Lee officials to tell them what was wrong with Jamaica that
necessitated the closure. One official could not comply. She kept making
very general statements and saying how good the Jamaican workers were
and that the company’s action was only a "business decision". She insisted
that she would not be dragged into politics, not by those in government or by
those who wish to be the government. This response has not satisfied the
quest for answers and the need to place blame. It may be that we are asking
the wrong questions so we are getting the wrong answers.

Global Operating Principles
In the 1980's, several Sara Lee Corporation (SLC) operating companies
developed and published their own "international operating principles". In
1992 guidelines were written for their suppliers/contractors. In 1994, focus
was placed on world-wide employee relations issues for owned and supplier
facilities; "new" Global Operating Principles and Supplier Selection
Guidelines were drafted based on existing division practices. Global
Operating Principles and Supplier Selection Guidelines were approved by
SLC senior management and introduced in 1995. Issues addressed in the
Global Operating Principles were:
* Ethical Practices   
* Laws and Regulations   
* Environment
* Community Relations
* Corporate Contributions
* Political Activity
* Communications
* Working Conditions and Workplace Safety
* Employment and Employee Training and Development
* Employee Recognition, Empowerment and Treatment
* Respect for Diversity
* Hours of Work and Age of Employment
* Compensation and Benefits

Sara Lee set out minimum standards that applied to the firms from which
they sourced their products. This included all contractors, joint venture
partners and suppliers of goods and services.

THE PLAN TO OUTSOURCE
Sara Lee Corporation currently produces goods through 986 companies in
52 countries and sells products in 140 countries. Almost 3 million people are
employed world-wide making products for SLC. In 1996, SLC decided that
their future growth would be achieved through contractors. This meant a
steady reduction in the number of factories they actually owned and
operated. This model epitomises the New Work Order. NIKE and Bugle Boy
now outsource all their production. Once you find contractors that can meet
your standards, world class companies have proved that identifying the
essential core of your business facilitates the highest productivity. The rest
can then be outsourced. For example, last year British Airways began
outsourcing cargo and baggage handling, some accounting and even the
flying of some routes. They now realise that the essence of being an airline
is the operation of reservation and traffic scheduling systems. For SLC it
was now time to catch up.

BEST PRACTICES
On February 20, 1998, Sara Lee hosted a "Best Practices Meeting" at the
Wyndham Rosehall Hotel. A team of senior managers was in attendance. All
the local companies that produced products for Sara Lee gathered to share
the procedures and ideas that work well in their factories. All the companies
were meeting and exceeding the standards and criteria set by Sara Lee. I
was invited to present a seminar on effective means by which performance
and production can be rewarded. I was also privileged to learn of some of
the great milestones that the local managers had achieved. We saw data on
world class, in-house management training programmes that had
significantly reduced staff turnover. Team sewing had been effectively
introduced increasing productivity to and beyond world standards. One
company even saved money by importing 9 buses to transport their workers
daily. Incentive programmes were devised to encourage perfect attendance.
Imaginative interventions such as managers helping workers to take care of
their business by making phone calls for them while they were at work. We
heard about in-house health clinics that provided Pap smear tests, STD and
birth control counselling and referrals to doctors. Other plants were
providing in service training for all workers, including basic literacy.

TEMPORARY SET BACK
I am not surprised at Sara Lee’s decision to cease operating the Sandy Bay
factory. It was obvious to me that the Jamaican plants and their managers
have reached world standards in their operations and production. Sara Lee
can rely on their contractors to consistently supply the volume and quality
that they need. I believe that the jobs lost in Sandy Bay are temporary. Other
contractors will soon absorb these well-trained workers, thus expanding their
own capacity.

What we now need is the government’s assistance in strengthening this
sector. One of the main ways to increase productivity is to remove the
income tax on overtime work, so the machines can be run for longer hours.
These workers compare themselves to their relatives who work in tourism
who earn tax-free gratuities. Both are critical foreign exchange earners.
Should they not get the same incentives? There is also need for better public
transportation and housing for workers. The plan to build more Freezone
factory space in Montego Bay is a mistake. Move the factories to where the
workers live. If the government really cares about this sector, now is the
time to do the right things.

 

 
Copyright © 1995 - 2012 Leahcim T. Semaj & Company Limited.
This site is best viewed with an 1024x768 screen resolution or higher.
Back to Top